Great to be back at Write....Edit....Publish
again, this time for the prompt “Sharing”.
I am here with a flash, a teeny bit over word count, but I can’t pare
it down any further without going crazy.
(If you are pressed for time or patience, then you could just cut to the
story from here by ignoring the next two paragraphs J thanks!)
Writing poetry in the first and
second person pov is much easier for me than fiction/prose. Most of my poetry is written in the first
anyways, not because it is autobiographical or anything, but simply because I
feel it has a greater immediacy and connects more deeply with the reader. But I am not as free and easy with the first
person in prose. The whole thing becomes
a pile of I, I, I and it is incredibly hard/tedious to wrestle the monotony out
of it. Writing second person is probably even
more awful.
However, what RFW and
now WEP has done for me (thank you!)
is to encourage me to venture out of comfort zones. So I have attempted a second person pov in
this flash. I would love to hear your
views on using it, how do you make it work, do you like working with it, any
tips and tricks. Above all, whether you
think it can tell a story more effectively than the others?
Strictly within limits
How do you know where to draw the
line? Time out of mind you have been
hearing it, “Play nice. Take turns.
Share.” And honestly? What choice is there when you are the eighth
child? True, treated a little special initially
because eighth children are special, particularly if they are sons. Well, you know the story about Lord Krishna
being the eighth child. But you are the youngest,
and resources are stretched, your father’s business of jute sacks is failing
because there’s a growing world of plastics out there. You learn from the very
beginning to make do. With
hand-me-downs. Books and shoes. Coats with holey pockets. You make do with sharing spaces.
Affections. Attention.
The job of raising you is delegated
to your elder sister, a child herself. Your
mother is often tired, she works two shifts that add up to more than the sum of
their parts in exhaustion. Your father is mostly away resurrecting a dying
product. The insecurities trickle into
the family somehow. Holey pockets, worn
soles and stretches of loneliness surrounded by the sea of an extended family; sharing
things that are never enough. You don’t
know any other ways of growing up.
There are others like you at school,
but you don’t know them either. You always feel the weirdest, most impoverished,
clinging onto some precarious pretence at normal life. You furtively compare your books with the
crisp new ones that some students buy, and yours look the most dog-eared, with
so many generations of scribbled annotations in the margins as to be useless
and illegible. You never make any
annotations yourself. You are a passable student with a meagre scholarship that
guarantees you will finish school, no matter what destiny decides about jute
sacks. You volunteer little of yourself
in classes, blend in between the last bench and the first somewhere.
A couple of students bully you. You deal with it. Do exactly as asked with aloof
impassiveness. You volunteer nothing of
yourself here either. It is an effective
defence and makes the bullies, and other people as well, quickly lose
interest. You get by with a carefully
constructed carapace of self-sufficiency over a jelly-like self-esteem.
The jute business finally crashes,
your father is now at home, frustrated, boiling with rage and seeking the softest
target available. That of course is your
elder sister, who is also your mother. Your real mother takes on some more extra
hours at work, that makes her practically disappear from home and your father
angrier than ever. He spends most of his
time yelling at everybody within earshot.
Worse things than yelling happen too, which you witness from the shared
bed, pulling the tattered covers over your ears. The bread becomes chewier, the lentils more
watery, the beautifully rounded scoops of steamed rice are shaped with smaller
ladles. You’re always hungry, there is
never enough food. The hand-me-downs
hang looser on your frame. Your carapace
becomes harder, your self-esteem more fragile.
An older brother escapes with the
housekeeping money, no-one hears from him again. Another goes away to the Gulf to work,
promises to send money home. But he
tumbles off a twenty floor high scaffolding, and then it comes out he was
illegally there so there’s no compensation.
A sister escapes too, elopes with a much older man, one of your father’s
former customers who’s transitioned now to modern packaging. This makes your father incandescent with fury.
He is openly violent with the women, when you try to intervene he cuffs you so
hard that you have to be taken to the hospital.
Home becomes intolerable, you hang
around the street corners and the old park more than you need. The park particularly, the grass there is
balding in patches, the benches are either bent or broken, only a couple of
lights work. Petty crime and clandestine romance are what mostly go on there. But it’s comfortable - no-one will disturb
you - you don’t carry anything that could lure pickpockets or prostitutes.
On a day of feeling especially raw
and fragile, a stranger asks if she can share the bench where you are grappling
with your maths, and then offers to split her parathas in exchange. You have to suddenly blink back embarrassing,
unmacho tears. She doesn’t pay any mind
to your efforts at brushing her off, insists you try some. So you do, just to
shut her up. She watches you wolfing down a paratha
at top speed and then offers you another in silence. Your mouth is too full of saliva, and your
guts twist too tightly to articulate a refusal.
You take it and wolf it down again.
She doesn’t ask many questions.
She is back the next day. You are
reading – “Yond Cassius has a lean and
hungry look. He thinks too much.” -
and trying to pretend you’re neither hungry nor thinking too much about her or
food. The pattern repeats. Some kind of shaky friendship results; it will last
till you graduate school, and the park, and the city.
A few weeks later she lights up a
cigarette and passes it to you, ”Try it, it’ll help you focus,” and you cough
and cough in the beginning but it does feel good. It’s just another thing to
share, you think nothing of it when she offers another. Because isn’t that what you’re supposed to
do, share and take turns? During a
slightly murky dusk, the light above the broken bench flickers on and then a
long off - the couples have withdrawn into the shrubbery, and the pickpockets
haven’t yet descended on their beats - she offers you a syringe. “Try it. Bloody wicked, man.” Your fingers fumble, you have never injected yourself
before. She takes it from your hand and
plunges it into herself first and then into you in one swift, practised movement. You wait for it to kick in and you think
nothing of it. Only remember it years
later at a clinic as a piece of paper flutters in your trembling hand and your
world comes crashing down. How do you
know where to draw the line?
WC -1025
All
feedback welcome.Read the other entries here
Hello Nilijana. Sorry, this Simply LInked is no fun. I can't delete either, but don't worry, your No 8 leads to this story. And what a story it is! So well told in the second person. I like first and second person storytelling, but I know some don't, so it will be interesting to see the differing opinions.
ReplyDeleteThe story itself was powerful, a wonderful sketch of life in a desperate household with all its frustrations brought on by not having enough. I just finished re-reading Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt. Another story of gruelling poverty and tragedy.
Thank you for posting for WEP. I love the way you managed to get 'sharing' into the story. If I manage to delete your second link I will.
Denise
Thank you, Denise. The very first mag I submitted to had a guideline that said "no second pov" - scarred me for life, probably! :) Glad to know this one's worked. Happy childhoods don't make for good stories, as FMcC says.
DeleteI'm fine with 2nd person, although I think it could get a bit much if there was a whole book full of it. Then again I did read a book lately that had a lot of 2nd person, because the character was talking to her dead sister ("you"), and it didn't bother me at all.
ReplyDeleteThis was a terrible story - as in so very depressing and sad. And yet you write extremely well and the story definitely had me gripped from beginning to end.
I feel sorry for this kid though :(
In which case, the story has done the job. Thanks!
DeleteIt's amazing how slippery that slope can become. Well written, I was rather hoping there would be an escape route in there somewhere after everything that had happened.
ReplyDeleteWhat a shocking piece! In the beginning, I could relate as the youngest child in a family five kids, and even how I felt at school.
ReplyDeleteAt first, when the girl/woman gives him a paratha I was filled with hope, thinking they would build a life-long friendship and even fall in love. But then she gave him a syringe and my stomach dropped. So shocking, but so wonderfully written. I don't believe I've read fiction in the second person before, but I really think you did an amazing job!
Nice work. Very compelling story. I hurt for your protagonist.
ReplyDeleteAnd yet I still see redemption in the future! Beautifully told, a sad but true tale for so many and yet possible to turn it around! Here is from where the true hero's arise!
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing!
I agree. A sad childhood's silver lining is the better ability to fight back as an adult. Thanks for being here, Yolanda.
DeleteWell done, very realistic. And congrats on tackling 2nd POV, it's definitely the toughest but you made it work.
ReplyDeleteThank you all for reading and the feedback. Much appreciated.
ReplyDeleteIt's a beautiful story and as a reader i can say that I really connected with it. I had an inkling of a tear in my eyes by the time i was done with it. However, I was dissatisfied because you ended it to quickly with the last few lines and sequence of events moving in too rapid a progression to follow with the kind of empathy one would like to feel.
ReplyDeleteBut maybe I felt that way because you've written it very well or you meant it to be that way.
Well written and it pulled me in right away. So sad. I disagree with Brendan. I thought the ending left the reader guessing what happened and that is good.
ReplyDeleteNancy
Thanks, Nancy and Brendan.
ReplyDeleteI think that 2nd POV is difficult, yet you seemed to mange very well. A raw and edgy real-life story. Great writing and flow of ideas.
ReplyDeleteI like the way you incorporated the "sharing" theme into your story. Smart.
Writer In Transit
Thank you.
DeleteLovely to meet you too Jen, and thanks for the kind words.
ReplyDeleteWow, this was chilling and sad. I love how you ended it, "How do you know where to draw the line?" Very effective. Thank you for sharing it...
ReplyDeleteGlad you liked it. Thanks for reading.
Delete