It's time to get back to Write...Edit...Publish... this month and I'm still with essays. Or memoirs, if you prefer. But there's a slight difference this time, more about that later. Here's my entry for Red Wheelbarrow...
Wheeled In, Wheeled Out
Memory is a cloud on a Himalayan slope,
slinking in through the open shutters and leaving everything misted with a
certain coolness, bedewed with moisture. Memory is a jewellery box, an old
radio, a cigarette holder between gnarled fingers; it is a suburban house that
morphs from cage to polestar depending on who is looking and if they are inside
or out. It is a mossy pump housing against which pinwheel flowers
bloom. A rockfall on NH 31 somewhere near Sevoke, the Coronation Bridge
on its peripheral vision. The smoke from a grandmother’s coal fired stove
stinging early morning eyes. And it’s also a decrepit wheelbarrow that Matthias
the gardener wheels in from somewhere with a heap of suspiciously smelly black
lumps.
Memory is forever a smell – of animal
dung fertiliser, of petrichor, the rains hitting parched ground in a needle
thin, sharp sheet of silver. Of the bushfire crackling across the drive from
the windows, of your mother spraying you playfully with Revlon’s Charlie as she
completes her dressing to go out. Everybody was crazy about that perfume in
those years caught between kiddiekidness and grownuphood. The Harmattan haze
like teased out cotton candy falling on the bougainvillea, just like that
Himalayan cloud only a different colour, a different smell, and dry as a
bleached bone.
From Dover Lane to Delhi. And then wheeled across several borders and seas nearly 7000 kms away, only the world
hadn’t gone metric yet so it was all miles still. When your mother told you
that you all would have to leave Delhi - your school, your friends, your entire
hitherto familiar world, you don’t remember being overly dismayed. Which was
strange for a child, now that you come to think of it more than four decades
later. But the bonds loosen automatically as soon as another home, another
city, another life of a different texture dawns as a possibility on the
horizon. That is what it has been like for nearly all the moves, bar
one.
Memory is the name of a friend from a
childhood city, a fixed telephone line recalled from another one, the exact
sound of your father’s car turning into the driveway when you were
thirteen. It is an atlas first and later a spinning globe, seablue
and mudbrown and icewhite and all the little countries marked out in different
colours – India in pale lime, Nigeria in peach. Memory is a strange sequence of
numbers and words – 18/68B Dover Lane and E-79 NDSE Part I and E-823 C.R. Park
and 46, New GRA. That small white painted sign listing next to the culvert
and the green 46 stencilled on it - memory is even tinier than the footprint of
that sign, but still as huge as the 46+ years that have lapsed since you saw it
first.
Parents and I in Maiduguri, early 70's. |
***
Airports in the early 70’s were more
basic everywhere, at least those you travelled through. No sleekness or
softness anywhere, no gleaming granite floors, no fancy lighting. Signages were
cruder, functional. No barcodes on baggage - bags got misplaced regularly. A
collection of hard chairs and hard floors, uncomfortable seating arrangements
in less-than-plush transit and departure lounges. Planes, on the other hand,
had something called legroom and seats that reclined more than 5 degrees, even
in economy.
Rome had uniformed security personnel
toting machine guns and an air of complete chaos – intimidating. Heathrow
even back then bristled with maps to go, the underground one was your favourite
right from the first. Kano had bright blue and orange agama lizards alongside
the runway, stopping to nod, nod, nod, three times in quick succession, before
skittering on. So much more interesting than the drab sand coloured geckos on
the walls back home in Delhi. Maiduguri was a windsock and a control tower
perched on the fringes of the Sahara when you landed on 29th April
1972.
Memory is a child’s delight at finding
the bottle of Coke supersized by a continent move, just like that - 300 ml
instead of the 200 ml available at the local paan biri shop
in C R Park. It is the wonder at seeing the baobab illustration in a favourite
vernacular story book come alive in the Sahel, so close! After the first
roundabout in the GRA and then again just before the turn into the drive of 46.
Something that a fictional hero might have sat under, now miraculously
available within the range of your own senses, to see, to touch, to scoop out
and eat the tartness of it fruits.
***
In the square hollow created by the
garage, walkway and the external wall of the kitchen, your father planted a
golden cassia sapling for shade so that future visitors had somewhere to park
their cars. It grew ramrod straight, its lower branches longer and heavier than
the higher ones, like a comical Christmas tree, the whole idea of shade and
parking somehow gone wrong. It topped the roof and rose higher in the years you
spent there. Memory is about vaguely wondering now, 46+ years later, if that
tree in 46 GRA still stands, and if by chance it does – has it grown a canopy
under which a car can be parked for shade on a scorching hot Sahel afternoon?
Memory is all about not knowing and having no means of finding out.
In the album there's still the last photo of your family with friends come to see you off when your father was relocated out of
Maiduguri. Your face reflects your misery – the only time you were
beside yourself with desolation, completely out of love with the idea of a
move.
The
humongous North Eastern state had been carved up into three, and two brand new
towns needed to be built up – from almost-villages to the state capitals. Resources
in Maiduguri were allocated to the new states and your father was one such
resource allotted to Bauchi. So goodbyes were said, the last bread broken,
promises of undying friendships made and addresses exchanged. One March
morning, NES 4579 was loaded up. You sat at the back window with an entire universe
worth of resentment churning within you, your elbow against a pile of stuff
teetering on the seat, held up at the other end by your mother’s help, Balai.
And so you were wheeled out of 46 New GRA and the Sahel for the last
time.
WC 1070 FCA
I'd be particularly interested to hear your views on the second person POV in the excerpt above. Do you think it works? Does it distance you from the narrative? Would you prefer to read memoirs in the first person only? Thank you as always, for your feedback.
Incidentally, 'Sahel' is an Arabic word meaning shore and it is used to refer to the fringe of the Sahara. The Sahel Savannah is a geographic zone stretching more than 3000 miles across Africa, from the Atlantic to the Red Sea.
This is a scheduled post as I am travelling this month. I will be reading as and when I can, but will catch up with each one of you once I am back. Meanwhile, happy reading!
Incidentally, 'Sahel' is an Arabic word meaning shore and it is used to refer to the fringe of the Sahara. The Sahel Savannah is a geographic zone stretching more than 3000 miles across Africa, from the Atlantic to the Red Sea.
This is a scheduled post as I am travelling this month. I will be reading as and when I can, but will catch up with each one of you once I am back. Meanwhile, happy reading!
Greetings. I really liked this perspective. And as always, your descriptions are just sublime. This is a wheelbarrow full of memory. Excellent.
ReplyDeleteContinued safe travels
Oh. And oh again. What a packed wheelbarrow you have given us. The scents (some black and lumpy), the sounds, the regrets...
ReplyDeleteAs always I was fully engrossed and didn't register the change of POV because your words took me there and triggered memories of my own.
Happy travels.
Until I got to your question, I hadn't noticed it was 2nd pov. I was immersed in the memories and the flow so I missed it! Which means I think it worked well as it wasn't disruptive or intrusive at all.
ReplyDeleteIt's a unique view. But second person makes it more personable than third. It's like those were my memories.
ReplyDeleteI didn't notice the POV either. Made me think of my own memories, behind yours.
ReplyDeleteBeautiful memories Nila. I hope you're writing a memoir. I like the second person 'you'. More direct for the reader. I think Rome was having terrorist bombs in the 70s which is why they had machine guns. I remember getting a shock seeing guards with guns in France too. Airports were targets in those days more than now.
ReplyDeleteI hope you've been safe in the many airports you've travelled via this trip. Soon home? Hope all is well and your son is settling in the good ole USofA.
Absolutely packed with emotion and memories that evoked my own memories and questions of places half known and half remembered. The change in POV was so smooth and 'right' that I, like the others before me, didn't notice it. Well done indeed.
ReplyDeleteHi Nila - loved reading the history here ... all woven across the continents - and your family's change due to your father's job. We all think back ... yet the answers are our own ... it's the way we work things out ... reminded me of much!
ReplyDeleteI hope you're writing your memoir ... or perhaps as here in chapters as you feel fit ...
I need to check out the places ... as some I'm not sure of - but loved the peach of Nigeria ... and pale lime of India ... at this point I was brought back to remembering stamp collecting ... as my knowledge was limited back then, and travelling wasn't yet a part of me ...
Take care and remember all those stories and memories you're gathering now - cheers Hilary
Memories of childhood, with all the senses intertwined to create the perfect whole. I think your second-person POV fits this essay the best.
ReplyDeleteSecond person was a great way to do it as it really made the sense of memory hit home.
ReplyDeleteAs others have said, second-person POV worked extremely well as did your words, evoking such memories from your life.
ReplyDeleteSecond person POV is a tricky one to use, but I think you did it masterfully here. It really helped me connect with this piece in a personal way. Your descriptions were marvelous and you evoked a lot of powerful emotions here.
ReplyDeleteThis is beautifully written. Airports in the 1970s in the United States were fun. I enjoyed flying as a child. These days I swear I'd rather walk, pushing my luggage along in a red wheelbarrow--ha!
ReplyDeleteMuch to absorb, like with travelling; it was a moment to connect with my wine; a breeze drifting in, still full of yesterday's rain; an instrument being strummed in a distant garden - and your words - all combined to make this brief vicarious journey enjoyable.
ReplyDeleteThe supersized Coke sounds familiar... :)
ReplyDeleteWhat a lovely memory, captured with such precision with powerful images. I especially appreciated the way the young narrator's emotions are shown, at times excited and then resentful of such dramatic change. For me, the second person pov worked very well to bring the reader closer to the story. Somehow, first person would seem to create distance. A beautiful read.
ReplyDeleteI didn't pick up on the POV right away, but I knew something was differnt. I felt like someone elses memories were mine. I guess that's how second person works. I like it for this piece very much. Wonderful descriptions. A fitting tribute to memory and all the little things, good, bad, and just part of life.
ReplyDeleteWhat vivid memories! The older you get, the more frustrating moving, and starting all over, can get. Kids can really suffer, even when the adventure is amazing.
ReplyDeleteI was not particularly drawn to the 2nd person perspective in this. I would have prefered 1st person, as you say, for the intimacy. This is well written, and I did feel a sense of sadness for the author, but I don't feel very connected. I'm not a real fan of 2nd person however.
Beautifully crafted. Really delightful read
ReplyDeleteSuch rich memories that felt alive. POV didn't take from them - they become both personal and universal. They sent me exploring too.
ReplyDeleteHi,
ReplyDeleteI have read many of your posts about your own life, but this one touched me the most. It is because I think writing a memoir in the second person awakens something deep in the reader and not just in yourself. This one awaken my own memories of my life with my father and mother. Writing in the second person did not distance me, it brought me closer.
By the way, I do hope that you continue your memoir in second person. You have the gift to put deep emotional feelings in it.
Shalom aleichem,
Pat G
A great example of how to use Second Person POV. Along with bringing a rich tapestry of imagery to life, as one adjust to new places, new friends, and new homes. Well done.
ReplyDeleteThank you all for reading and the feedback.
ReplyDeleteAs always, your descriptions are incredibly evocative. I don't think I'd care for a whole book-length memoir in the 2nd person, but in a piece like this, it seems to create a stronger sense of nostalgia than you could ever get with either first or 3rd person.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Rebecca. Totally agree with you. Fine for 1000 word length one-off essays, but tedious to read and possibly alienating in a longer work.
Delete