Assume, just for a mind bending minute, that Islam didn’t get as far as India, that they did
an about turn, both the marauders and mystics alike, from the Hindukush. What would India be like then? The short answer to that question is - abysmal.
What would we have missed out on? The first thing that comes to mind is no Amir Khusrow, so no ghazals, no sitar. Indian music, both classical and light, particularly the North Indian stuff would sound completely different, a much paler version of itself. But hang on, not just Indian music. Fast forward seven centuries and take a shufti at the 1960s and that would sound quite dismal too. No sitar would mean no Ravi Shankar, no collaborations between George Harrison and the Indian maestro, no songs such as Norwegian Wood, which is on the list of 500 greatest songs of all time. Yup, one less on that list. Let that sink in while you take a listen.
There are a whole heap of other things too, of course. The luscious architecture of the Taj Mahal, for instance. Distinctive art of the Mughal paintings too, these guys were seriously into the pursuits of refinement and sophistication. Firearms and gunpowder, brought into India by the first Mughal king, Babur, from Turkey. Then there's the cuisine - all time favourites, droolworthy dishes like the Biryani, the Kaliyas and Kormas, kababs of all kinds. The list could go on - the jewellery styles, such as the nose ring, and body art such as the henna tattoos; drier things like seamless celestial globes, maps and astrolabes; paper mills, spinning wheels and iron stirrups; more abstract things like the expansion of trade and economy. Without these, India would be unrecognisable.
But what is perhaps the most far reaching impact was that education was liberalised under the Mughal emperors. Hinduism, mired in its caste system by medieval times, restricted education based on birth. The Muslim rulers upended that - they promoted the exchange of ideas, set up educational institutions where anyone could go learn, voraciously translated Sanskrit texts into Arabic and Persian and vice versa. Islam brought in the idea of universal brotherhood and equality which was instrumental in the later reform movements such as the Bhakti movement and the rise of other belief systems like Sikhism.
So...had the Muslims turned back from the Hindukush, India would have been a vastly different, much poorer place altogether. Far less attractive really, if you ask my free and frank.
Absolutely astounding - definitely interesting to think about the what would have happened (or not!) with the "ifs" of history. Applause - good start to the month. As always, your journeys make me think.
I love alternate history stories. I am not sure one has been written on your "what if" but it's all logical. It would be interesting to read - maybe you could be the one to write that story? However, history does take strange paths, and that story may not be quite what any of us think.
Hari OM ... I understand your point, Nila - but I have to put my hand up for the Veena and Carnatic music, both 'home grown'! There is much which belongs to the original culture of 'pure' Bharata. However, as with all countries, it is the blending of cultures from migrations which enriches and broadens a national identity, of that there is no doubt. Thus the sadness when such as recent upturn in 'them and us' thinking seeks to tear it away... YAM xx
Hi Nila - this is brilliant ... and yes that 'what if?' question ... life could so easily be so different. What if the need to trade, and thus travel hadn't occurred - we'd have never have known so much of the world, or what it can offer ... I hope that today's world of technological developments will apply in 200 years ... loved your A for Assuage our Curiosity ... cheers - Hilary
Absolutely astounding - definitely interesting to think about the what would have happened (or not!) with the "ifs" of history. Applause - good start to the month. As always, your journeys make me think.
ReplyDeleteI love alternate history stories. I am not sure one has been written on your "what if" but it's all logical. It would be interesting to read - maybe you could be the one to write that story? However, history does take strange paths, and that story may not be quite what any of us think.
ReplyDeleteHari OM
ReplyDelete... I understand your point, Nila - but I have to put my hand up for the Veena and Carnatic music, both 'home grown'! There is much which belongs to the original culture of 'pure' Bharata. However, as with all countries, it is the blending of cultures from migrations which enriches and broadens a national identity, of that there is no doubt. Thus the sadness when such as recent upturn in 'them and us' thinking seeks to tear it away... YAM xx
Yes. A loud and emphatic yes - and an amazing start to your A-Z.
ReplyDeleteGreat A post, it's good to read you again ;)
ReplyDeleteQuilting Patchwork & Appliqué
Very educational A, I liked it!
ReplyDeleteHi Nila - this is brilliant ... and yes that 'what if?' question ... life could so easily be so different. What if the need to trade, and thus travel hadn't occurred - we'd have never have known so much of the world, or what it can offer ... I hope that today's world of technological developments will apply in 200 years ... loved your A for Assuage our Curiosity ... cheers - Hilary
ReplyDeleteIt's been so long since I've heard Norwegian Wood. I'd forgotten the sitar.
ReplyDeleteThat would have made life in the rest of the world a little less worh living, too...
ReplyDelete