For F I am responding to two of my Favourite poets today. One from the East and the other from the West, Faiz Ahmed Faiz (Roshniyon ka shahr - The City of Lights) and Robert Frost (Acquainted with the Night) respectively.
Faiz, Faiz Ahmed (1911-1984)
and
Frost, Robert (1874-1963)
Light and Dark
There are
cities of light, and cities of dark
and I’m
acquainted well with both, as most are;
I’ve lain awake
nights when some dagger-spark
throbs and
fades in every false-hearted star.
And I have
seen too the queued up lampposts
pollute the
shoreline of the foam-fringed ocean
however far
one walked, the silent ghosts
of light
ran alongside out in the open.
I held up
my words of booming darkness
I made sure
those black wicks were trimmed and low
But the
huge litter of light never grew less,
never left
me alone in peace even so.I often get the Feeling that Fiction is more readily accepted as...um...Fictional, i.e. imaginary. Readers have a harder time accepting that poems can be imaginary too, that they are not necessarily mirroring a cardinal truth in the poet's own life, or anyone else's life for that matter! What do you think - is poetry Fiction or Fact?
And F is for Four (hundred), which is the max word limit for A-Z posts according to those who commented on the question here yesterday. And this post's way less than that, even at the end of this line :)
Posted for the A-Z Challenge 2015
Poetry is like prose - it can be whatever the creator wants it to be.
ReplyDeleteHi Nila - oh dear my posts are exceeding the 400 .. thankfully people still read. Yes - I like Alex comment - he's always to the point .. Yours I enjoy as I do like to understand what I'm reading though!! Cheers
ReplyDeleteI love to write fanciful poetry. It's so much fun to dive into my imagination. I think poetry can be anything. :)
ReplyDeleteI think poetry can be both fiction and fact. Or anything it wants to be. Only the poet knows and that is the beauty :)
ReplyDeleteI hadn't truly thought before about whether poetry could be fictional -- but it makes perfect sense. Whenever we use words, we're exploring emotions and feelings and all kinds of things. The framework could be a story, or a poem, or whatever works best. Nice post!
ReplyDeleteVery very good, and I've read a lot of poetry where it was fictional, but always with a meaning that held fact. Really enjoyed this! Lisa, co-host AtoZ 2015, @ http://www.lisabuiecollard.com
ReplyDeleteI think both prose and poetry is fiction and facts. It's fiction in the story on the surface and truth about the nature of human beings >:)
ReplyDeleteCold As Heaven
I think both prose and poetry is fiction and facts. It's fiction in the story on the surface and truth about the nature of human beings >:)
ReplyDeleteCold As Heaven
Very interesting :) I write a fiction and poetry blog and the question you raise is a valid one. I write both fictional and non-fictional poetry. I also feel that fictional poetry is still rooted in our experiences and perhaps coated with the story to conceal the complete truth. Lovely verse there.
ReplyDeleteFound you via the A-Z Challenge :)
*Shailaja/Alternate Angles/A-Z*
Poetry can be fiction, or fact, or just a way to express an emotion. But so can prose. It's all about how you choose to use the words.
ReplyDeleteI love fanciful poetry too. It helps me delve into my innermost thoughts and feelings whereas my regular writings are non-fiction. Btw, I'd never heard of either of the poets you're referring to.
ReplyDeleteI love Robert Frost. I agree that people often think poetry must be intensely personal, but I don't think that's true...I think it's a perfect vehicle for imagination!
ReplyDeleteWhen I was young, Robert Frost was probably the first poet anyone could name. One of my teachers made everyone memorize "Stopping By Woods on a Snowy Evening."
ReplyDeleteWhen I was young, Robert Frost was probably the first poet anyone could name. One of my teachers made everyone memorize "Stopping By Woods on a Snowy Evening."
ReplyDeleteI would say poetry can be either or anything the author intends it to be. In fact doorwaybetweenworlds.com states it much better than I do but that is what I also think.
ReplyDeleteThank you for the nice comment on my blog.
The English word 'poem' seems to have come from Greek and Latin words meaning 'create', so I think poems are more like fiction than fact. However, we could write about facts in the form of a poem, too.
ReplyDeleteI think that's the beauty of poetry. It can mean different things to different people. I could see your troubled lone walker not being able to sleep and not being able to disappear into the night like they wanted.
ReplyDeleteYou can find me here:
ClarabelleRant
very baautiful poetic on F.
ReplyDelete